Peter Pan — The Ultimate American Diner on Bay Shore

There is something about American food that is poignantly comforting. The excess of fats and sugar makes its way straight to the heart, evoking feelings of joy and satisfaction.

Interestingly, American cuisine is influenced by different cultures: Italian, Dutch, French, British, and Caribbean, and now their food has become a staple in American food. Some popular American dishes that are loved around the world include chicken wings, tater tots, hot dogs, apple pie, barbeque ribs, Reuben sandwiches, meatloaves, grits, and hamburgers. 

Living in America, the options for American food are unlimited, but not all diners are created equal. In the same way, Long Island has its fair share of restaurants that boast delicious American fast food; however, many of them end up disappointing customers with their bland flavors and poor quality.

Peter Pan Diner on Bay Shore

Peter Pan Diner is located at the heart of Bay Shore, offering its customers mouth-watering and authentic American food that delights their taste buds. The restaurant also provides take-out and food delivery services for times when you are in search of a quick fix.

No matter what you’re craving, you are sure to find it on Peter Pan’s exciting menu. Have a look at what is in store for you at Peter Pan.

  • Daily specials
  • Soups
  • Toast and muffins
  • Eggs and omelets
  • Breakfast wraps
  • Peter pancakes
  • Griddle specialties
  • Appetizers
  • Salads
  • Paninis
  • Quesadillas
  • Triple deckers
  • Peter Par wraps
  • Sandwich classics
  • Specialty chicken sandwiches
  • Specialty burger
  • Hot dogs
  • Dinner entrees
  • Captain Hook’s seafood
  • Side dishes
  • Beverages
  • Desserts
  • Ice cream shakes

Now, isn’t that a thrilling menu? If there’s confusion about what you can order from all these options, you can always refer to the bestsellers on the menu and order a people-favorite.

Here are some of the best-selling American dishes at Peter Pan diner. See if you can spot any of the popular American dishes we discussed above.

  • Texas smoke
  • Reuben
  • Meatball parmigiana hero
  • Taco wraps
  • Pepperoni pizza fries
  • Roman holiday quesadilla
  • Chicken gyro
  • Cowboy burger

No meal can be complete unless finished with a rich and decadent sweet treat. Peter Pan Diner checks all the right boxes with their delicious desserts, including 7-layer cake, apple pie, baklava, blueberry pie, Boston cream cake, cheesecake, cookies, lemon meringue pie, and more.

The ice cream shakes are equally tempting with Hershey’s ice cream and flavorful toppings. If you enjoy ice cream shakes, you should try out the cookies n cream, minty mint chip, and mocha-choco-latte shake at Peter Pan.

What customers say about Peter Pan Diner

Peter Pan Diner is a favorite spot for American cuisine on Long Island. Here is what customers have to say about their food and services.

“Mmmmm…I love their hamburger sliders. They are very tasty. I usually order it with curly fries, yummy.”

“If you will looking for a gyro, I swear this is the best place on Long Island to get a gyro with the Greek salad, and the source it’s just awesome also, the Roman Holiday is to die for.”

“Service is great, staff very friendly and the food is terrific, quick service great place been coming here for years.”

Subscribe To The Newsletter

For everything Long Island

For Everything Around Long Island